Independent · No paywall · theindeks.com[email protected]
The Indeks
The world, measured.

Market / Money

Market · Analysis

French borrowing costs near a 24 year high, and the street is part of the price

Ten year French yields climbed to 4.96 percent on Tuesday, within a whisker of levels last seen in 2002, as the unrest met a budget France cannot pass and a debt it cannot shrink. The street has a vote. So does the bond market.

La Defense, the Paris financial district, seen from the Eiffel Tower. File photo.
File photo: La Defense, the Paris financial district, seen from the Eiffel Tower. File photo. Photo: Gugalcrom123, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0.

The region, on the map

Paris, France, pinned where this story happened, with every other place-led Indeks story.

See it on The Indeks Map

The second front of France's crisis opened on a trading screen. The yield on ten year French government bonds climbed 3 basis points on Tuesday to 4.96 percent, after Monday brought the biggest daily rise in nearly a month. Earlier in October the same yield touched 4.9937 percent, a level last seen in July 2002. Investors are not panicking about France in the abstract. They are repricing the specific thought that the euro zone's second largest economy has a government that cannot pass its budget, cannot cut its deficit, and now cannot keep its own streets quiet either.

The number that matters most in Paris is not the yield itself but the gap. The spread between French bonds and Germany's benchmark Bunds widened by about 5.5 basis points to roughly 152.5 basis points, territory last associated with the euro debt crisis, and earlier this month it reached 158.67 basis points, the widest since November 2011. Italy's spread rose too, which is how traders say the word contagion without saying it. France now carries debt of about 119 percent of GDP, and every basis point on that spread is real money added to the cost of carrying it.

The stock market took its turn on Monday. The CAC 40 fell 1.4 percent, led by the banks and by the companies whose shops had filled the news. Societe Generale dropped 2.7 percent, BNP Paribas and Credit Agricole about 2.5 percent each, and LVMH lost 2.2 percent after its stores were among those looted. Carrefour fell 1.8 percent after 50 of its stores were ransacked, damage its chief executive put at more than 10 million euros in repair costs alone. A riot is a policing problem for one weekend. Priced into a bond yield, it becomes a cost the state pays every day for years.

The strategists are unusually blunt about the trap. Benjamin Schroeder at ING argues the protests show that any French government will struggle to deliver the reforms and savings the debt requires against this level of public resistance. Christoph Rieger at Commerzbank frames the same point from the other side: the markets are calling for austerity while the streets are calling for spending, and no government in Paris can satisfy both at once. Jamie Searle at Citi calls the risk premium investors now demand to hold French debt uncharted territory, which is a banker's way of saying nobody knows where it stops.

The tests arrive in order. The National Assembly votes on Tuesday on the revenue side of the 2027 budget bill, a vote that would normally be procedural and now reads as a verdict on whether France can govern its finances at all. On Saturday the protest movement returns to the streets, with curfews in force and a state of emergency held in reserve. The curfew may have calmed the boulevards, but calming the bond market takes a budget, a majority and a quiet country at the same time. Paris currently has none of the three, and the yield is simply the price of that sentence, updated every second.

4.96%: the yield on ten year French government bonds on Tuesday, near the highest level since July 2002

The Briefing

The day's world, market and sport, measured and in your inbox before breakfast. One email, no noise, free while we build it.

Subscribe by email

Subscribing opens your email app with a note to [email protected]. We never share your address.